High Court orders injunction in EMJ Plastics confidential information case

EMJ Plastics has welcomed further High Court orders protecting its confidential information and specialist expertise, including a final injunction against competitor Mekina Industries Limited and a £385,000 interim payment towards EMJ’s legal costs.

The orders, made by the High Court of Justice of England and Wales on 26 October 2026, follow an earlier judgment concerning the copying and misuse of confidential EMJ information by former employees involved in establishing a competing business.

The Court has also ordered the preservation of electronic evidence and financial disclosure to establish the financial consequences of that conduct.

For EMJ, a British manufacturer with more than 60 years of experience in specialist glass reinforced plastic (GRP) products, the proceedings as we explored in our previous article on why experience matters in protecting GRP expertise, have been about protecting and safeguarding the technical knowledge, investment and expertise behind the products and services its customers rely upon.


High Court orders further protection for EMJ’s confidential information

At the latest hearing, the High Court granted a final injunction preventing Mekina Industries Limited and its directors, Ian Baggaley and Mark Johnson, from using documents taken from EMJ’s systems.

The injunction takes immediate effect and covers material copied onto a hard drive, EMJ’s confidential December 2022 “Hot List” of prospective customers, projects and business opportunities, and documents copied, extracted or derived from those materials. It also applies to those acting on the Defendants’ behalf.

The orders follow the Court’s earlier findings that former EMJ Operations Manager Ian Baggaley copied over 11,000 company files onto a hard drive for use in a competing business, retained confidential material after leaving EMJ and subsequently used company information at Mekina.

The Court also found former EMJ employee and Mekina co-founder Mark Johnson liable for the subsequent misuse of confidential EMJ information, although it did not find that he was involved in the original copying of the files.

The Court rejected important parts of the explanations given by Mr Baggaley and Mr Johnson concerning the retention and use of EMJ documents, finding that both had given untrue evidence on significant issues.


£385,000 costs payment and further financial investigation

Alongside the injunction, the High Court ordered an interim payment of £385,000 towards EMJ’s legal costs and directed further steps to establish the financial consequences of the misuse of its information.

These include an inquiry into EMJ’s losses or, at EMJ’s election, an account of profits made by Mekina as a result of the unlawful use of confidential information. The Court has also ordered financial disclosure concerning Mekina’s permanent formwork business.

Relevant electronic repositories must be preserved through independent forensic imaging, ensuring that evidence remains available for the next stage of proceedings.

The trial judge refused the Defendants permission to appeal. They may still apply directly to the Court of Appeal.

The financial assessment is not yet complete, and EMJ will not speculate on its outcome.


Why protecting specialist GRP expertise matters

Established in Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, in 1964, EMJ Plastics has developed specialist GRP products, manufacturing capabilities and technical expertise for more than six decades.

Its Permadec permanent formwork systems have been used on more than 5,000 UK structures, supporting bridge construction, civil engineering and major infrastructure projects. EMJ also supplies its technology internationally.

Its experience spans early development and testing of reinforced GRP permanent formwork alongside the Department of Transport, and continued investment in product development, specialist manufacturing and technical support.

That experience underpins EMJ’s customer work today: successful permanent formwork requires not just a manufactured product, but design capability, technical understanding and practical experience.

Sean Minihane, Director of EMJ Plastics, said:

“This has never been an action we took lightly. EMJ has spent more than 60 years developing specialist products, technical knowledge, expertise and customer relationships, and we believed it was important to protect what our people and our business had built.

“The High Court made significant findings about the copying and use of our documents. The orders now prevent the Defendants from continuing to use material derived from EMJ’s information and provide a framework for determining the financial consequences of that conduct.

“We welcome the clarity the Court’s decisions provide. Our intention throughout has been to protect the expertise behind our business, not to prolong a dispute.”


Our focus remains on our customers and the future

Throughout the proceedings, EMJ has continued manufacturing and supplying specialist GRP solutions for construction, infrastructure and civil engineering. The orders protect confidential information developed through decades of investment and experience, allowing EMJ to focus on the work behind its reputation.

“Customers do not simply buy a manufactured component. They rely on the technical understanding, experience and specialist knowledge behind it,” Sean added.

“Protecting that expertise is a responsibility we take seriously. While further financial assessment remains to be completed, our priority is firmly on the future and on continuing to develop the products, capabilities and relationships that have defined EMJ for generations.”

EMJ will continue investing in its people, technical capabilities and specialist GRP products, including its established Permadec GRP permanent formwork range. For customers and project partners, dependable products, experienced technical support and the specialist knowledge needed for successful projects remain the priority.


Further information

The proceedings are EMJ Plastics Ltd v Mekina Industries Ltd and others, case number IL-2024-000145, before the High Court of Justice of England and Wales.

The original High Court judgment can be read in full on The National Archives website.

Further proceedings will determine the financial consequences of the misuse of EMJ’s confidential information.